Chris Lancelot: Leave GP services to Darwinian selection

I find it fascinating that Darwin's principle of evolution by natural selection applies not just to biology but to systems in general.

But remember - the whole point of natural selection is that the system itself will evolve to find the best way of working only if we don't artificially interfere.

Of course this is the opposite of what control-freak politicians want to do, especially those who believe in massively centralised government.

The Achilles' heel of the command and control model is the quality of information flowing from the periphery to the centre. If this is not both accurate and comprehensive then decisions made centrally won't work - which is exactly where the NHS is at the moment. It is a very expensive and exceptionally inefficient system.

Take general practice. The centralised model suggests that GP practices need monitoring and controlling to force them to deliver what the NHS needs. That is why we have QOF targets, enhanced services and public surveys, all in place to try to tell the DoH who is good and who is bad. But because these measurements are superficial, scatter-gun and unrepresentative they don't do the job. They are also expensive to operate.

Now compare this with the Darwinian approach. Practices are already autonomous and in competition with each other. Provided they are left alone by government and given a level playing field, those that fulfil their patients' needs and expectations will attract more patients, survive and prosper. Those that do not will lose patients and, unless they change, ultimately fail.

This system is cheaper because it no longer requires hordes of administrators to monitor it. It is also more effective, because the judgments made by large numbers of patients are vastly more sensitive than any survey or set of statistics. Using this approach, practices are automatically encouraged to improve - at reduced cost.

Allowing practices to survive or fail through natural selection will create a cheaper, better primary care system. It is one way the NHS can save money while simultaneously raising standards. How sad that, although the principle of evolution has been known for 150 years, many politicians and managers have not learned its lessons.


Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins


Already registered?

Sign in

Just published

Medical centre sign

One in three GP practices in Northern Ireland faced serious closure risk in past 18 months

One in three GP practices in Northern Ireland have faced a serious risk of closure...

BMA sign

BMA warns Treasury 'many practices' will close without emergency financial support

GP leaders have urged the Treasury to agree emergency funding to support general...


Practices can use £172m PCN cash to support staff pay rises, GP leaders say

Practices can use their share of Β£172m from the 2023/24 investment and impact fund...

GP typing at computer

EMIS apologises for 'human error' that caused major GP IT system crash

EMIS has apologised to GP practices hit by a major system failure that left them...

GP consultation

GP practices delivering 10% more appointments per day compared with 2019

GP practices in England delivered 10% more appointments per working day in the first...

computer and stethoscope

Major IT system outage heaps pressure on GPs over bank holiday

A major IT system failure that left GPs across England unable to access patient records...