Chris Lancelot: Consortia will need iron fist to keep discipline

A chain is only as strong as its weakest link, and, for consortia, the weakest link will be less-capable practices. No matter how dedicated the rest, a handful of incompetent, lazy or politically disaffected practices will foul up a consortium's entire operation.

The GP Record, by Fran Orford www.francartoons.com

Given the notorious independent mindedness of GPs, how will consortia monitor and control their practices?

Will consortia be able to jettison practices that don't achieve the consortium's objectives? If not, what will they legally be entitled to do to discipline them? Fine them? Disbar them from receiving grants, pump-priming money, bonus payments or management fees? What legal constraints will be put in place to ensure fair play, both over the assessment and monitoring of practice effort, and in relation to any disciplinary action?

Who will issue the practice contract - the NHS Commissioning Board or the consortium? If it is the Commissioning Board, all practices will have to submit large amounts of data to justify the continuation of their contracts - bureaucracy and data collection that we had all hoped would disappear under the White Paper's proposals. Conversely, if the consortium holds the contracts there may be less need for separate data submission, but it will be all too easy for personal vendettas, misunderstandings or incompetent appraisals to cause victimisation.

In any case, how does one judge one's fellow professionals? Even if assessments are performed by GPs, what is to stop them from doing it in the blunderbuss manner of NHS Bedfordshire, surcharging practices that don't conform to simplistic prescribing targets, ignoring individual GPs' professional opinions, and without exception reporting? Practice appraisals in the brave new world of the White Paper will have to be vastly more sensitive than this.

Consortia will neither be able to keep control of their budgets, nor make commissioning work properly without legally based, ethical and robust mechanisms for assessing, confronting and, if necessary, punishing poor performance.

So politicians beware: unless you give consortia real teeth, and practices real protection, your proposals will fail dismally.

Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Register

Already registered?

Sign in

Follow Us:


Just published

phone and laptop

Blanket rollout of patient record access programme halted

Plans to roll out access for all patients to prospective entries to their GP medical...

GP sign

Scottish GP capacity hits lowest point in more than a decade

Scotland has lost 3% of its full-time equivalent (FTE) GP workforce since 2019 -...

coins

GPs fear funding cuts and sidelining of LMCs as ICS model beds in

GPs fear hospital trust overspends could become 'general practice's problem' as representation...

Doctor on a computer

3 reasons why recruiting with GP Jobs makes your life easier

How GP Jobs can help you fill vacancies in your practice.

Amoxicillin antibiotic drug capsules

Viewpoint: How can we reduce antibiotic prescribing?

Dr Anita Sharma, who has been involved with several antibiotic prescribing initiatives...

Person typing on laptop

Complaints against GPs up 37% compared with pre-pandemic levels

Written complaints about GP practices have surged by more than a third compared with...