MPs reject GP's e-petition bid to scrap Health Bill

MPs have rejected a GP's call for the Health Bill to be scrapped after a Commons debate.

Dr Chand stressed his support for the NHS was non-political.
Dr Chand stressed his support for the NHS was non-political.

MPs defeated a Labour motion based on Greater Manchester GP Dr Kailash Chand’s e-petition which called for the Bill to be dropped.

Shadow health secretary Andy Burnham said: ‘I beg to move, that this House notes the e-petition signed by 170,000 people calling on the government to drop the Health and Social Care Bill; and declines to support the Bill in its current form.’

The motion was then amended to leave out ‘Bill’ and add ‘declines to support the Bill in its current form; and calls for an urgent summit of the royal colleges, professional bodies, patients’ organisations and the government to plan health reforms based on the Coalition Agreement.'

The motion was initially lost by 314 votes to 260 as a whole and then MPs rejected the original motion without the amendment.

Speaking before the vote health secretary Andrew Lansley accused Dr Chand of being an 'adviser' to the Labour party.

Mr Lansley said: ‘I am grateful to the right honourable gentleman, but before we move beyond that point will he confirm that Dr Chand is an adviser to the Labour party, which inspired the petition?'

Dr Chand said he was very disappointed and sad that the motion had been lost and stressed his support for the NHS was non-political.

‘This is nothing to do with party loyalties,’ Dr Chand said.

Before commenting please read our rules for commenting on articles.

If you see a comment you find offensive, you can flag it as inappropriate. In the top right-hand corner of an individual comment, you will see 'flag as inappropriate'. Clicking this prompts us to review the comment. For further information see our rules for commenting on articles.

comments powered by Disqus


A-Z listing of therapeutic areas. Find the latest clinical news and education


Browse a list of all of the pages and topics on GPonline

Pain Resource Centre

Information on chronic and neuropathic pain

Otitis Externa Toolkit

Resources to help treat this outer ear infection

GPs practising in the UK can request to receive free copies of GP by completing our online registration form. For paid subscriptions to GP visit our subscriptions site.