Chris Lancelot: Red tape and regulations are rotting the NHS
By Chris Lancelot, 05 February 2010
Last week, I wrote about Parkinson's third law: 'Growth leads to complexity, complexity to decay', and remarked on how relevant it is to the massively inefficient NHS.
As if on cue, two news items leapt out confirming this. The first was about the problems facing paediatric surgeons.
Because of their specialism, many travel all over the country to operate. However, they are hindered from working efficiently because every time they come to a new trust they have to undergo a fresh Criminal Records Bureau (CRB) check, which can take six weeks. In the meantime they are not allowed to work there with children.
The second report described how a doctor or nurse could be cleared of professional misconduct by the GMC or the NMC - yet still be prevented from working because the new Independent Safeguarding Authority (ISA) might take a different view of the same case. Worse - there are only limited rights of appeal against ISA decisions.
You couldn't make it up, could you?
Why has the government become so paranoid about professional standards? Not content with triple jeopardy it now wants to subject us to quadruple jeopardy (GMC regulation, criminal law, civil law and the ISA) - presumably 'to protect patients'.
Why isn't a GMC hearing enough? Has it not occurred to the government that quadruple jeopardy is both pointlessly complex and manifestly unjust - especially as court cases can drag on for years, leaving doctors suspended, or alternatively unemployable while under investigation?
What clueless apparatchik dreamed up the tortuous regulations under which CRB checks must be performed from scratch by each new employer? These checks were intended to prevent danger to children, but instead have produced exactly the opposite effect, delaying their access to surgery.
Why can't a professional receive just one CRB check, then be given either a 'CRB passport' or alternatively a website reference number so that each and any new employer can view their credentials, instantly? Or is that too obvious?
As Parkinson said, complexity leads to decay. The government urgently needs to learn this lesson before it gums up the NHS completely.
Additional Information

Latest jobs Jobs web feed
- Salaried GP The Practice plc £75-85k FTE +NHS pension, Ely or Leicester
- Regional Clinical Leads The Practice plc Salary £95-105k FTE + NHS pension, Leicester or Sheffield
- Salaried/Lead GPs Malling Health Competitive, role dependant, NHS Pension and defence fees reimbursed, Nationwide
- GP'S REQUIRED FOR ON-GOING SESSIONS IN OXFORD,£70 PER HOUR,OOH,WIC AND SUGERIES Merco £70/hour, Oxfordshire
- Full Time Salaried GP required Briarwood Medical Centre Extremely competitive, Preston, Lancashire
- Salaried GP, Sheffield, Full time One Medicare Up to £80,000 per annum, NHS Pension and Medical Indemnity, Sheffield
Most read
- Health secretary says GPs have 'ethical duty' to save NHS costs
- NHS Commissioning Board chairman rebuked for 'golf-playing GPs' jibe
- Government department sessions (where BMA 'Treasury rate' is accepted)
- GPs face 'outcomes targets overload', patient group warns
- DH could face legal challenge over risk register veto
- NICE to develop multimorbidity guidelines for GPs
Most commented
MIMS Drug Search
Possible searches include drugs (by brand, generic ingredient or drug class), diseases and more.







