Mary Selby - The NHS may be in chaos, but it is still working
By Mary Selby, 22 February 2012
Chaos theory is sometimes called the butterfly effect. And if a butterfly flapping its wings in Brazil can cause a tornado in Texas, what Richterian disaster might result from my failed attempt to put Mrs Enormous into the left lateral position?
If I had studied chaos theory before now I would never have made her get onto the couch at all. It is never wise to ask anyone to climb onto an object smaller than they are, particularly not one with a wobbly leg. I felt not to do so would be fattist. It turns out that to do so was in fact daftist. Now she has an appointment with the practice manager and I have a bruise the size of Bedford.
Mathematicians define chaos as a state of disorder, which fits exactly with the actuality of Monday morning emergency surgery. The defining features of chaotic systems are that, while complex, they rely upon a strict underlying order (and frankly the order that governs the NHS feels positively totalitarian), and that small variations can cause large changes.
So in chaos, nothing is truly predictable, apart from the fact that the future is unpredictable. This means we can't say that I was already doomed long before the moment when I was first trapped by Mrs Enormous' right leg then crushed against the carpet as the wobbly leg decided to fold, but we can say that the progression to disaster was predictably unpredictable.
We can also say that when a woman of Wagnerian construction wants an intimate examination, a GP the size of a stick insect should not be attempting it alone.
Government should learn from this. The consequences of the crashing couch are nothing compared with the consequences of enormous changes to that Leviathan system of predictably unpredictable chaos that is the NHS – for what more extraordinarily chaotic system is there?
Somehow it works, against the odds, probably because all the bits of chaos are endlessly corrected back into something resembling order by a mixture of goodwill, panic and sheer bloody-mindedness. Politicians tamper with the foundation stones of such a beast at their peril. Mr Lansley risks a crushing by an awful lot of thighs.
Additional Information

Latest jobs Jobs web feed
- Salaried GP The Practice plc £75-85k FTE +NHS pension, Ely or Leicester
- Regional Clinical Leads The Practice plc Salary £95-105k FTE + NHS pension, Leicester or Sheffield
- Salaried/Lead GPs Malling Health Competitive, role dependant, NHS Pension and defence fees reimbursed, Nationwide
- Locum GP's needed in the South Coast MSI Group Ltd £70 - £80 per hour, South Coast
- GP Locum, Lancashire Fresh Medical Recruitment £500 per day +, Lancashire Locum
- Locum GP's Required Surrey! Global Medics Locums £££ Up to £650 per day, Surrey
Most read
Most commented
MIMS Drug Search
Possible searches include drugs (by brand, generic ingredient or drug class), diseases and more.







