Exclusive: UK 'must hold overseas doctors to account'
By Nick Bostock, 14 May 2009
GP son of man killed by German doctor calls for tougher checks and training for overseas doctors.
Foreign doctors working in this country should be held to account under UK law for any mistakes they make, says the GP whose father was killed by German doctor Daniel Ubani.
West Midlands GP Dr Stuart Gray's father David died last year when Dr Ubani accidentally gave him an overdose of diamorphine. Dr Ubani has been struck off by the GMC, but continues to practise in Germany after receiving a nine-month suspended jail term there.
Dr Gray told GP: 'Dr Ubani came in, did a shift, killed my father and has gone back to Germany. He is not accountable to UK law. I think doctors should be accountable in the country they work in, and once a restriction is placed on their practice, that should apply across the EU.
'I can't see how you can commit a negligent act in one country and continue to work in another.'
Dr Gray added that Dr Ubani had had a 'few hours' of induction, and that was not enough to work in UK general practice.
He said that doctors who do not work as GPs in their own country should not be able to work as one here - Dr Ubani works primarily as a cosmetic surgeon in Germany.
The fact that Dr Ubani did not face trial in the UK also denied Dr Gray's family the chance to have any input.
'My dad's partner would have been able to say what happened, and have some input into the case if it had taken place in the UK,' said Dr Gray.
He added: 'The GMC does not know how many foreign doctors are practising in this country.'
The family is seeking an independent review of the incident, which has led to calls for a review of out-of-hours care across the UK.
Comment below and tell us what you think
Additional Information

Latest jobs Jobs web feed
- Salaried GP The Practice plc £75-85k FTE +NHS pension, Ely or Leicester
- Regional Clinical Leads The Practice plc Salary £95-105k FTE + NHS pension, Leicester or Sheffield
- Salaried/Lead GPs Malling Health Competitive, role dependant, NHS Pension and defence fees reimbursed, Nationwide
- Newly qualified GP's dr-locums £70 an hour plus, Nationwide
- Full Time Partner (9 sessions) Charnwood Community Medical Group Equal share partner, Loughborough, LEICS
- Locum GP Meddoc Locums £600-£800 A day, London & Essex
Most read
- Health secretary says GPs have 'ethical duty' to save NHS costs
- GPs face 'outcomes targets overload', patient group warns
- LMCs Conference 2012 - Live Blog
- QOF errors trigger £1,000 top ups and clawbacks
- Women to be screened later for cervical cancer in Scotland and Wales
- LMCs conference 2012 - Full coverage
Most commented
MIMS Drug Search
Possible searches include drugs (by brand, generic ingredient or drug class), diseases and more.







