Lawyers warn of substantial costs of consortia hiring PCT commissioners
By Susie Sell, 02 September 2010
GP consortia could face substantial payouts if they need to make ex-PC commissioners redundant, legal experts have warned.
Dr Grenville: 'not optimistic' (Photograph: Jason Heath Lancy)
Lynne Abbess, a partner at specialist law firm Hempsons, said GPs should start thinking about the management support they might need when they take on commissioning.
Ms Abbess said the 'obvious' option is for GPs to take on PCT commissioners, but added that if they are transferred under Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) regulations (TUPE), this could create workforce and financial problems for consortia.
She said: 'It is worth taking good PCT commissioners in under TUPE. It is a positive thing to do. TUPE will apply if the consortia take over activity carried out by the local PCT.
'But GPs need to understand that TUPE operates like an act of God and they may also have to take on people that they do not want.'
Ms Abbess warned that if PCT commissioners are transferred under TUPE arrangements, GPs could be liable to pay the total employment term for that individual if they have to make them redundant later down the line.
Ms Abbess said there were other options, such as bringing in PCT staff from other areas, which could mean they were effectively new employees.
She suggested GPs could consider bringing in staff who have dealt with procurement in a different context, or using private companies that already have the skills and infrastructure.
Dr John Grenville, a GPC member, said GP consortia would be keen to retain good NHS managers. He added that the DoH could smooth the transition by making money available to consortia for them to carry the risk of having to offer large redundancy packages. But he said he was not overly optimistic this would happen.
Additional Information

Latest jobs Jobs web feed
- Salaried GP The Practice plc £75-85k FTE +NHS pension, Ely or Leicester
- Regional Clinical Leads The Practice plc Salary £95-105k FTE + NHS pension, Leicester or Sheffield
- Salaried/Lead GPs Malling Health Competitive, role dependant, NHS Pension and defence fees reimbursed, Nationwide
- Newly qualified GP's dr-locums £70 an hour plus, Nationwide
- Full Time Partner (9 sessions) Charnwood Community Medical Group Equal share partner, Loughborough, LEICS
- Locum GP Meddoc Locums £600-£800 A day, London & Essex
Most read
- Health secretary says GPs have 'ethical duty' to save NHS costs
- GPs face 'outcomes targets overload', patient group warns
- LMCs Conference 2012 - Live Blog
- QOF errors trigger £1,000 top ups and clawbacks
- Women to be screened later for cervical cancer in Scotland and Wales
- LMCs conference 2012 - Full coverage
Most commented
MIMS Drug Search
Possible searches include drugs (by brand, generic ingredient or drug class), diseases and more.







